When I was in 11th grade, a group
of Israeli kids came to visit our public school. They discussed their lives,
touched on Israeli politics and spoke frankly about different aspects of
Israeli society, their impending draft into the Israeli army and their complex
relationship with a complex society. The visit was an intensely meaningful one
for me and helped cement my decision to make aliyah.
Various Jewish and Israeli institutions,
including the Jewish Agency, the Israeli Foreign Affairs Ministry and several
private organizations continue to organize such visits but the young
ambassadors can't reach every school.
Last week JETS used distance learning to "bring"
a young man named Ze'evi , to the classroom of Yeshivat Kadima where
he spoke about his military service in a combat unit.
Ze'evi spoke frankly about the difficulties
of serving in sensitive areas, specifically serving in the Judea and Sameria region. The students have
heard, and debated the different issues involved, but the real-time visit with
Ze'evi helped them to see the concerns from the perspective of someone who had
actually served in the region.
Ze'evi
discussed subjects that the JETS-Yeshivat Kadima Contemporary Jewish Issues
class has been exploring during the past year, including the dilemma of whether
Israel should negotiate with terrorist organizations in order to free captives.
The kids had many questions. They asked about
the military operations in which Ze'evi participated, the qualifications that
combat soldiers must have, how soldiers request a specific unit, Hesder
yeshivahs, etc.
The students were particularly interested in
hearing Ze'evi's view of the media reports that they've read criticizing the
Israeli army, specifically the charges that the army indiscriminately hurts and
kills Palestinians. Ze'evi responded
from the standpoint of a former soldier, explaining that soldiers
frequently find themselves in dangerous situations but, per army rules, aren't
able to do what they would have liked to
do to protect themselves and their fellow soldiers. He summarized the soldiers' frustrations at
the situation and noted that no other army in the world goes out of its way to
protect civilians in the way that the Israeli army does.
boys class |
The students had many more questions which
demonstrated the depth of their curiosity about the possibility of aliyah, as
well as their evolving personal connections to Israel. One young student asked
Ze'evi to summarize the most meaningful experience that he had as a soldier.
Ze'evi gave a few examples relating to the camaraderie of the soldiers, but
noted that one of the most moving moments of his army experience occurred when
he visited the kotel with his unit and was asked to pose with an elderly
American tourist. As the man, a Holocaust survivor, stood with 20 young soldiers he began to cry,
and, Ze'evi, the grandson of Holocaust survivors, cried with him.
No comments:
Post a Comment